Skift Take

Are old-school U.S. airlines too focused on short-term profits and competing against low-cost carriers to deliver a quality product to their loyal passengers?

Editor’s Note: Skift’s Business Traveler newsletter is now the Business of Loyalty newsletter.

In this weekly missive, we’ll bring you the same insight into what matters most to the people who travel for a living, but now with an added focus on how airlines, hotels, and credit card programs battle for their attention and their business — a points geek with a Ph.D. of sorts. 

While we are still looking at how these moves impact the consumer, the focus is on what the industry is doing to win their loyalty. The newsletter is being written by Grant Martin, who you’ve come to know as the author of our Business Traveler newsletter over the last three years. He’ll be able to take advantage of contributions from Skift editors including Brian Sumers (airlines) and Deanna Ting (hotels) in order to better explain what’s happening with loyalty right now. We hope you’ll stick with it, and we promise to never devalue your reading experience.

Not long ago, it made sense for elite members in an airline loyalty program to book the cheapest airfare on the market and expect to receive a modicum of decent treatment from the airline in return. Free upgrades, checked baggage and snacks all came with various levels of elite status and passengers knew that despite booking a bargain-basement (or office-mandated) fare, it would be a journey in relative comfort.

Basic Economy fares, however, which American, Delta, and United are now integrating in full force, are now starting to supersede those perks and erode the basic values that loyalty programs used to provide. On each carrier, the restrictions are slightly different; Delta takes away upgrade perks, seat assignments, and the rights to change a flight. American takes it further by reducing earned award miles and rescinding overhead bin space. And United goes even further by slashing elite qualifying miles (though earned miles remain in tact).

Some of these restrictions such as the overhead bin rule are eased for loyalty program members with elite status, but others, such as upgrade restrictions apply across the board.

At first, frequent flyers took the introduction of basic economy fares in stride — after all, the fares were originally billed to compete with low cost carriers and only integrated on a handful of routes. But now, the fares are spreading aggressively and passengers are getting agitated. Last week, United confirmed that it had rolled out its fare to all of its domestic routes. Delta, content with its domestic strategy, is now expanding basic economy to international routes. And though American has only integrated the fare into a handful of routes, most expect that carrier to follow suit.

Some passengers overexposed to the fares have taken to social media to respond. “In reaction to this nonsense I just booked my first ever [Virgin America] flight, SAN-SFO,” said one United traveler on FlyerTalk, who apparently holds top-tier 1K elite status with the carrier.

Late last month, Zach Honig, editor of The Points Guy, wrote about United’s “infuriating” basic economy strategy, calling some of the pricing “insane.” Among the comments in that piece, one reader admitted that “as a United Platinum flyer I have stopped flying with them. It’s not worth it to deal with the hassles. I will fly with an [Ultra Low Cost Carrier] or a [Low Cost Carrier] over them just because I know what I am getting into.”

It’s tough to broadly conclude that passengers are actually leaving their favorite carriers and abandoning loyalty programs en masse — after all, the only story that airlines will tell is that revenue is up and that loyalty programs are only improving. But there’s a real sense of discontent flowing through the passenger base around basic economy fares — and sooner or later, something’s going to give.

Subscribe to the Business of Loyalty Newsletter

Skift Stories and More Expert Insight

Alaska Launches Promotions Just for Regional Loyalty Program Members

In a time where most airlines are making drastic cuts to loyalty programs, Alaska Airlines appears to be headed in the opposite direction once more with a new promotion aimed at travelers flying through the west coast.

Alaska’s Mileage Plan program continues to get stronger with a new series of incentives aimed at west coast Virgin America customers. Between the incentives and the numerous partners, Alaska has put together a pretty solid loyalty program.

Clever Ways Basic Economy Fares Force Flyers To Pay Extra

Predictably, basic economy has been condemned as yet another step in the industry’s relentless drive to strip all comfort and grace from steerage class. But there’s a shell game going on here—this consternation overlooks a far more insidious change: While adding these new bargain-basement fares, carriers also raised prices on traditional economy seats.

Four Seasons CEO Sees ‘Airbnb Effect’ in Luxury Hospitality

Four Seasons isn’t taking Airbnb’s push into high-end lodging lightly.

Interview: Marriott CEO on Politics, Technology and Loyalty

Arne Sorenson is not the kind of hotel CEO who likes to stay quiet about the most pressing issues impacting not only the hotel business, but travel overall.

The Wall Street Journal: Even Elite Frequent Fliers Find Fewer Airline Perks

The decline in airline amenities that has vexed consumers in the back of the plane is now hitting elite frequent fliers, too.

Australian Business Traveller: Four Seasons hotels to introduce luxe loyalty program

Four Seasons is planning a guest recognition program to bolster loyalty in an era where plush bathrobes and free high-end toiletries are standard, as it seeks to sharpen its focus on refining guest service. [Note: Skift told you about this first over two years ago.]

Have a confidential tip for Skift? Get in touch

Tags: alaska airlines, american airlines, delta air lines, jetblue airways, loyalty, united airlines, virgin america

Photo credit: A promotional image of a seat back in United Airlines' Economy Plus section. United Airlines

Up Next

Loading next stories