Airbnb CEO responds to illegal rentals story: “First of all, it’s not illegal everywhere”

Skift Take

Chesky's statement at the PandoMonthly event about Airbnb working with local authorities conflicts with interviews we did with local authorities. They characterized discussions with Airbnb as a "one-way street" trying to legalize their business model.

-Jason Clampet

Last night, PandoDaily founder Sarah Lacy interviewed Airbnb CEO Brian Chesky at a sold-out event in the tech blog’s PandoMonthly interview series. Chesky used the opportunity to address Skift’s story from earlier this week about illegal rentals in New York City and other markets.

Sort of.

During the interview Chesky chose to focus on what he described as “unknown” rules for companies like Airbnb as well as the the strength of Airbnb’s screening system.

» Get your daily dose of Skift: subscribe to our newsletterRSSTwitter or Facebook.

“Many of those regulations existed before you had modern technology,” Chesky told Lacy after she asked about illegal listings. The law in New York State that affects Airbnb and other vacation rental companies was written and passed in 2010 and became law in 2011. According to state officials, the law was designed to both streamline and modernize existing laws that were complicated and outdated.

“First of all, it’s not illegal everywhere,” Chesky said. “It’s legal in most places in the world.”

Chesky discussed the larger challenges of the sharing economy and local laws: “A lot of businesses are being started in the sharing economy. And a lot of these businesses, whether it’s like Uber or like Lyft or Sidecar … Many times they’re going to have these regulations. They’re going to be unknown regulations, uncertain, they are always at the city level so they’re sporadic and they’re vast across like 30,000 all across the world. And they’re primarily set up for screening. To protect consumers.”

“Well it turns out that cities can’t screen as well as technologies can screen. Companies have these magical things called reputation systems,” Chesky said.

“We think government should exist as the place of last recourse.”

Watch the portion of the interview where Chesky addresses Skift’s story:

» Get your daily dose of Skift: subscribe to our newsletterRSSTwitter or Facebook.


Also seen at: PandoDaily

Follow @jasonclampet

Tags: ,
  • Matt

    Brian Chesky is a moron. First of all the New York Illegal hotels law is a state law, not city. Second its people like him who go to different places where they doesn’t know nor care about the reality of the working class in a given area and how they struggle to keep their homes. These laws were designed to keep the abuses by landlords of tenants in check. Get the your facts straight and do your damn homework.

  • Vviv

    Just because “it’s not illegal everywhere” ignores why these practices HAD to be made illegal in NYC and other urban areas. The crush of tourist traffic in these cities and the mania to cash in on it has made it all but impossible for the people to live and work here to survive. Has Chesky ever had to live with a new crowd of kids partying all night every weekend in the apt next door to his? Maybe he’d think twice about the terrible consequences of his business model if he did.

  • http://www.connectme360.com/ Brian Hayashi @connectme

    Brian had a golden opportunity to reassure the investment community about AirBnB and how it is working with critical stakeholders to enable a golden age of adaptive reuse. I am a Denver native who loved them when they launched here during the 2008 DNC, but I also saw firsthand the reaction from Denver landlords. They’ve had four years to figure it out, yet they are acting like the landlord laws are either to be flouted or are somehow unfairly targeting AirBnB.

Subscribe to a daily dose of news from Skift