As hotel occupancy plunges to a single digit, Hong Kong’s leadership toward one of its most important industries is being put to the test during the coronavirus crisis. So is the leadership of hotel CEOs in keeping their companies whole.
Hong Kong hotels these days are feeling forsaken not just by guests but government, which excluded them from a $4 billion (HK$30 billion) coronavirus relief package announced last week. Comparisons with Singapore add salt to the wound, with the Lion City seen as more empathetic towards hotels’ plight and more forward thinking.
The Federation of Hong Kong Hotel Owners, the Hong Kong Hotels Association, and independent hotel companies such as Ovolo Group have all lobbied for meaningful government aid that would help them survive and are waiting with bated breath if this will be forthcoming in Hong Kong’s annual budget scheduled this week.
>> Get the Latest on Coronavirus and the Travel Industry on Skift’s Liveblog
Hong Kong hotels last week were dismayed at being excluded from the $4 billion relief funding, about half of which would go to one-off cash injections to retailers, food and beverage providers, transport firms, students, the arts and culture sector, guesthouses and travel agents — no mention of hotels. The rest is largely for fighting the virus itself.
In contrast, Singapore unleashed a relief funding of $3 billion (S$4 billion) to support businesses and jobs, plus additional measures including a property tax rebate of up to 30 percent, corporate income tax rebates, and an 8 percent offset of wages for every local employed for three months from August 1. For a labor intensive and high operating cost industry, those are meaningful initiatives that Hong Kong hotels also want.
“We’re not necessarily looking for [cash] handouts. Can we look at waivers of rates and rents for a year? Income tax holidays?,” Tim Alpe, chief operating officer of Ovolo Group, told Skift.
“Can we subsidize energy and other costs that are regulated by government? These are all significant operating expenses for us.”
In his open letter to the government last week, Alpe asked, “Why have the city’s hotels been forsaken in the recent relief measures?” The industry is at the heart of Hong Kong tourism, which contributes to more than 4 percent to gross domestic product. Hotels’ biggest contribution is jobs, aside from huge revenues to government coffers from taxes and such, he told Skift.
Yet “we have been left to fend for ourselves,” when “the situation is beyond fight for market share, it’s now about survival.”
Hong Kong is now getting 3,000 visitors a day, from 90,000 overnight visitors daily in February last year, he said. “We are seeing hotels reducing operations and even closing their doors, restaurants failing, redundancies across the board and unpaid leave for employees.”
Hong Kong Hotels Association was also “disappointed upon realizing that the hotel sector had been left out in the cold,” said its executive director Patrick Kwok.
“We have written to the government since last year when the social unrest saw 60 countries issuing travel advisories against Hong Kong,” said Kwok. “We hope there’s a phase two in relief measures. We understand the government needs some time to come up with measures that focus on different industries. We hope we are on the list.”
In January occupancy was around 30 percent, Kwok said. “Now, we hear that occupancy is closed to a single digit. Average room rate is down by 40 to 50 percent. It depends on the category of hotels and the location. For example, airport hotels are doing a little bit better.”
Kwok however said only a small number of individual hotels that’s part of the association has closed. The association has 140 members comprising 58,000 rooms. Hong Kong has 300 hotels with 83,000 rooms.
“They [members] are reducing the scale of operations with measures such as closing a couple of floors due to the slowdown in business. But basically all are operating right now,” said Kwok.
Hotel companies with strong backing are in a better position to weather the crisis than small ones. Wharf Hotels, for instance, backed by legacy Wharf Holdings, decided to close its 394-room Prince Hotel on Monday for a 15-month renovation, dumping the original plan to keep the hotel open and renovate the property in phases from this month which, under current conditions, could result in major staff reductions. Instead, staff of the hotel have been redeployed to its two other sisters in the same cluster, Gateway Hotel and Marco Polo Hongkong Hotel. The three hotels have a total of 1,500 rooms.
The well-located Prince Hotel on Canton Road has been a favorite of global business and leisure travelers since 1984 and will reopen in third-quarter 2021 as Marco Polo Prince Hotel.
Wharf Hotels president, Jennifer Cronin, who has a PhD in crisis management, is using the downturn “to find new ways of doing things and getting the troops together, so that we will come out at the other end of this a much stronger and more efficient team,” she said.
The chain has been able to keep staff by terminating outsourced contracts where possible and getting these work done by its own staff instead. As well, associates are now on various up-skilling and training programs. Corporate Social Responsibility is also key, with staff involved in projects such as cleaning up Hong Kong’s hiking trails and producing coloring books that are sent to the Children’s Cancer Foundation.
Langham Hospitality Group, backed by another legacy, Great Eagle Holdings, also puts its heart on taking care of staff.
“Our properties are pretty much empty shells without our colleagues,” said CEO, Stefan Leser. “We have to strengthen their morale, especially those in Hong Kong and China, and there is a deep sense of responsibility about this from our hotels to the corporate office.”
For a chain whose positioning is encouraging guests to “Celebrate the Everyday” at its hotels, be it an anniversary occasion or a special event created by its properties, Leser admits that times have gotten tougher.
“During the [pro-democracy] protests, there was still F&B. Occupancies were still around 50-60 percent. Now it’s all significantly down. We have to accept the new normal brought upon us by events of the past eight months. That said I am confident Hong Kong will regain its position. Its fundamentals as a global financial center and an exciting world city are still there. So it’s prudent to prepare now and make sure we are in the best shape when the business is back,” he said.
Despite everything, confidence hasn’t forsaken Hong Kong. Robert Williams, head of hotels and hospitality Asia-Pacific, Withers Worldwide, said the company is involved in some operator selections in Hong Kong and “we’re not seeing these [negotiations] being impacted by the short-term issues Hong Kong is facing.”
The only thing that may happen is an extension of construction timelines on new-builds, since the supply chain is now interrupted by delays in mainland China, he said.
Hong Kong Hotels Association’s Kwok added that hotels that pipeline hotels are continuing to open as scheduled this year, for example, the 840-room Hotel Alexandra, part of Harbour Plaza Hotels & Resorts.
Owners Versus Operators
And what of hotels that are under the management of global hotel chains? The test here is how well international chains can show that in dire times, they are effective partners, according to hotel investment consultants.
“Hong Kong has been hit hard. Owners want to know what their operators are doing to mitigate the immediate downside, and to rebuild business when times improve. Any owner-operator relationships that were strained before coronavirus are likely to be further tested, and both sides will be keeping a close eye on performance guarantees, performance tests and force majuere provisions,” said Withers Worldwide’s Williams.
Owners will also look to the global operators for best practices in health and safety for both staff and guests, leadership through this with a clear strategy and, no doubt, some empathy, Williams added.
“As ever, communications will be very important, and that is hard in a fast-moving situation. Integrity will also be important from a relationship perspective — the coronavirus headlines in markets not heavily impacted may be used by weaker operators as an excuse for poor performance. Critically reviewing the data and accurately assessing both causes and opportunities should be a priority.”
Global chains will be trying their level best — don’t forget they hurt too, said Robert Hecker, managing director of Pacific Asia for Horwath HTL.
As management fees are tied to revenue/gross operating profit, operators are also affected in a significant way, Hecker pointed out, although admittedly they have a regional spread to diversify coronavirus impacts, unlike owners with only Hong Kong hotels.
“During a period of business stress, operators are definitely working with owners to reduce costs and seek government financial support. [Inducing demand] in such circumstances I would say is not possible.”
So what’s the use of global chains in such crises?
“They could be putting their maximum attention on achieving maximum capture of the business that is available in the market. They could work with owners to determine the best methods of reducing expenses. They could offer fee stand asides and perhaps some critical owner costs that affect the viability of the ongoing hotel operation/funding,” said Hecker.
Fee stand asides are when the operator pauses management fees due to it, giving priority to other operating expenses or certain owner costs such as property taxes, property insurance and debt service. The management fees in such situation typically remains payable, but the operator is flexible on when it’s paid.
Operators interviewed by Skift indeed are taking these measures.
Of five global chains Skift surveyed — Marriott International, Accor, Hilton, InterContinental Hotels Group (IHG) and BWH (Best Western/WorldHotels) Group — IHG has the largest number of hotels in Hong Kong (13), followed by Marriott (11), BWH Group (10), Accor (six) and Hilton Hotels (two). All said their hotels are doing business.
“We very much see our owners as long-term partners in our business and we are here to support them however we can and deliver above-market performance to their hotels,” said Michael Issenberg, chairman and CEO Asia-Pacific of Accor. “We are communicating regularly with owners to see how we can reduce the impact of the current situation and we will continue to review as the situation unfolds to ensure the long-term future of our hotels.”
“We have provided advice on how to reduce costs and measures that can be taken during slower business periods to ensure they are ready to outperform when business resumes,” added Issenberg. “This includes taking the opportunity to implement repairs/maintenance or renovations that need to take place; offering staff additional training to prepare them for when business rebounds; implementing reduced operating hours for bars and restaurants and innovating F&B offerings; and in some cases redeploying staff to other Accor hotels.”
Similarly, Alan Watts, president of Asia-Pacific for Hilton, gave Hilton purchasing and supply management as an example of how it is helping owners cut costs and remain profitable. “We are negotiating with multiple vendors, including technology partners, to reduce maintenance fees and costs,” Watts said. “But our primary focus is the health, safety and well-being of our guests and team members.”
David Kong, CEO of BWH Group, also said the chain empathizes with its Hong Kong owners and are putting plans in place to lessen their financial burdens although at press time he’s not able to reveal the plans.
When, Green Shoots?
In a slew of interviews with Hong Kong hoteliers, February is when the “new normal” has really sunk in, March is written off, April may see some green shoots, but recovery will only be after the first half of 2020.
That’s partly because big events that are demand generators have postponed to later in the year, such as Hong Kong Rubgy Sevens (now in October, from April) or taken a holiday in 2020 entirely, such as Art Basel Hong Kong, which was to have been staged in March.
The elephant in the room however is that if coronavirus goes away, whether social unrest will continue.
“While the 2003 SARS [Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome] proved to have nearly no lingering effect on Hong Kong hotels, with occupancy levels in excess of 70 percent merely one month after being declared SARS-free, the return of social unrest could deal the industry a mortal blow,” said Antonio Teijeiro, a hotel general manager and specialist in greater China, speaking in his own personal capacity.
“With this in mind, hotel companies must keep a very close eye on Singapore as it will not be faced with these additional unknowns and will adapt its offer to lure Hong Kong visitors,” he said.
Giovanni Angelini, former CEO of Shangri-La Hotels & Resorts who has gone through SARS, couldn’t agree more. “The political protests must be resolved. Everyone now has a better appreciation of the importance of the hospitality industry to Hong Kong — a clear opportunity to gain stronger support and recognition from the authorities, in particular on allocation of funds. The virus-aid package is not impressive at all. Hong Kong has a large amount of financial reserves for rainy days.
“Are these not rainy days?”
Tags: coronavirus, hong kong, singapore
Photo credit: Hong Kong's Victoria Harbour. dbrooker1 / Flickr.com