Skift Take

Despite a vocal minority of unhappy loyalty program members, Marriott still appears to be dominating loyalty rankings. Perhaps this squeaky wheel doesn't need any grease.

Series: Business of Loyalty

Travel Loyalty News

The Skift Business of Loyalty covers the world of hotel, airline, and other consumer loyalty programs in the travel industry. Read more coverage of loyalty here.

Ever since the merger of Marriott Rewards and Starwood Preferred Guest and the subsequent rebrand of the program to Bonvoy, there’s been a small but loud minority of loyalty program members who are furious with the changes and the new product. They’re very active on social media. They launched But it was never clear how representative they were of the total body of Marriott loyalty members.

Last week, some hard data surfaced to help color that narrative. For the annual Freddie Awards, which rank loyalty programs, Marriott dominated the loyalty category, taking home the prize for Program of the Year and Best Redemption Ability in North America as well as Best Elite Program in Europe and Africa.

Over seven million business traveler votes were counted to tally this year’s Freddies. “What’s sometimes forgotten in this day and age of everyone having a microphone is that Bonvoy has 120 million members,” said Randy Petersen, founder of Flyertalk, Boarding Area, and the Freddie Awards. “The negativity hasn’t come from 120 million members. Marriott, much like other programs that have been around this long, know the ‘silent majority,’ who have mostly not been affected by the changes.”

This isn’t to say that Marriott and the Bonvoy program should be free from criticism — this year, they lost the top spot for best elite program and best customer service to Hyatt and Caesars, respectively. What it does suggest, however, is that the silent majority in Marriott’s network is soldiering on despite the changes — and that Marriott will too.

— Grant Martin, Business of Loyalty Editor

Skift Stories and More Expert Insight

Rosewood Hotel Group CEO: ‘We Want to Push the Hotel Industry to Another Level’: It’s only been eight years since the former New World Hospitality group — a division of the larger Hong Kong-based conglomerate Chow Tai Fook Enterprises — purchased luxury brand Rosewood Hotels for $229 million. And in that time, Rosewood Hotel Group CEO Sonia Cheng has made it her singular goal to take the brand global, as well as retain its luxury heritage and make sure it remains relevant.

Alaska Air Slows Its Growth as It Focuses on Absorbing Virgin America: Alaska Airlines has a message for investors who ask if the airline is permanently slowing its growth: It’ll be on the move soon.

Allegiant Air Execs Angrily Defend Airline’s Hotel Strategy: Allegiant Air executives could have spent Wednesday’s earnings call bragging about their remarkable 22 percent profit margin. Instead, they took considerable time to criticize and mock investment analysts who have questioned their model as the company’s focus moves away from aviation and into hotels.

Marriott and Southwest Airlines Top Annual Loyalty Awards: Marriott and Southwest Airlines on Thursday night once again took top honors at the annual Freddie Awards, recognizing the top travel industry loyalty programs. A few new players, including Hyatt and IHG, were able to sneak onto the podium, too.

How Finnair Got It Wrong in China: Finnair’s plans to take a greater slice out of the growing Chinese travel market have suffered a setback after the airline group’s plan to focus on individual travelers failed to pay off.

Rising Costs Catch Up to Spirit Airlines: The upward momentum of Spirit Airlines may be starting to slow down.

United Airlines Unveils New Paint Scheme: In teasing that a United Airlines new paint scheme was coming, CEO Oscar Munoz recently called it more of an evolution than a revolution. He wasn’t joking.

JetBlue Is Betting New London Routes Will Boost Credit Card Revenue: JetBlue probably will never make the massive credit card revenue some of its peer airlines earn. But it can still make more money from its relationship with Barclays.

Low-Cost Carrier Allegiant Seeks Permission to Fly to Mexico, Finally: Allegiant Air has teased us before about flying to Mexico. But the airline is probably serious now. Will smaller-market travelers want to visit Mexican beaches as much as Las Vegas and Orlando? We’ll see.

Subscribe to Skift’s Free Business of Loyalty Newsletter

Grant Martin [[email protected]] curates the Skift Business of Loyalty newsletter. He is director of product marketing at TripActions. Skift emails the newsletter every Monday.


The Daily Newsletter

Our daily coverage of the global travel industry. Written by editors and analysts from across Skift’s brands.

Have a confidential tip for Skift? Get in touch

Tags: loyalty, marriott, marriott bonvoy

Photo credit: Despite a vocal minority of unhappy loyalty program members, Marriott still appears to be dominating loyalty rankings. Marriott

Up Next

Loading next stories