United Flight 93 co-pilot’s wife challenges view of what happened onboard on 9/11

Skift Take

United Flight 93's passengers got all of the media glory. The co-pilot's widow doesn't downplay their efforts, but gives the crew its due.

-Dennis Schaal

If you missed Melodie Homer’s recent talk at Wilmington, North Carolina’s Barnes & Noble, you missed a sizzler.

Homer is the widow of LeRoy W. Homer Jr., the first officer (co-pilot) for United Flight 93, the airliner that crashed near Shanksville, Pa., on Sept. 11, 2001, after being hijacked by al-Qaidaterrorists. Other planes hit the World Trade Center towers and the Pentagon. The terror team on United 93 was apparently aiming for the U.S. Capitol but was thwarted by some action by the crew and passengers.

A decade later, this lady is still hurting — and she is not suffering in silence. In “From Where I Stand,” she speaks her mind and takes names.

Terrorists aside, Homer has bones to pick with a large number of people. She is no great fan of the Bush administration, which she thinks missed several warnings of a potential terror attack pre-9/11. She doesn’t like most of the media depictions and re-enactments of United 93′s last hours, although she is more forgiving toward Paul Greengrass’ 2006 film version.

And she takes exception to the behavior of several of the Flight 93 relatives, whom she thinks behaved like hot-dogs with the media. Lisa Beamer — whose husband, passenger Todd Beamer, issued the famous declaration “Let’s roll” in one of his last cellphone messages — comes in for particular scorn. Lots of passengers made last calls on their cells from the air, Homer notes. Many of them, however, chose not to publicize them.

Homer particularly objects to Flight 93 narratives which seem to depict the United crew as relatively passive and credit the passengers with most of the heroism. Knowing what she does of a Boeing 757′s layout, she challenges the version that has passengers crashing through the cockpit door using a beverage cart as a ram.

LeRoy Homer, she points out, was the only crewman on any of the hijacked jets to get off a “Mayday” (distress) message on the radio, which he was handling. Cockpit voice recorder messages indicate that Homer and pilot Jason Dahl were not killed immediately, as some narratives suggest. She theorizes that her husband, or Dahl, was able to sabotage the controls, so the hijackers were not able to handle the jet with ease.

From the moment on the morning of Sept. 11, when an airline receptionist told Homer, “I promise you, everything is OK,” United Airlines comes off badly in “From Where I Stand.” Homer and other widows had to struggle at length for survivors’ benefits, even as United’s CEO was departing with a “golden parachute.”

Homer herself would suffer for years with the physical and psychic symptoms of post-traumatic stress. She returned to work in the health-care industry, though, and worked hard to raise the couple’s young daughter, who was less than a year old when her father died. Since the Homers had planned to have more children, she even adopted a young boy as a single parent.

Behind her pained account stands the figure of LeRoy Homer: a former Air Force major, a veteran of Desert Storm who had dreamed of flying since he was a little boy. His widow describes a man who filled his time away from the cockpit with trips to museums and landmarks, and who loved to talk to his infant daughter in a high-pitched “Elmo” voice. If America needs another hero for Black History Month, LeRoy Homer fits the bill. ___


  • KC

    People deal with grief in different ways and I guess her way is to just be mad at the world. Her truth differs from others but it doesnt make her right and them wrong. I’m glad the family members of the victims told their stories and allowed the world an opportunity to know the loved ones that they lost.

  • arguethefacts

    Todd Beamer NEVER said “Let’s Roll.” He spoke to an operator. The call was not recorded. She reported what she remembered of the call, which did not include the famous “Let’s Roll.” Later a reporter suggested he might have said something like that, and got the operator to say that he had said that. It was made up by a reporter.

    Reporters/writers have been doing that forever. News Flash: George Washington never cut down a cherry tree either. A writer later made that up, too.

  • stella

    Seems like an odd story, it feels like unless she is
    personally recognized, and her husband, she does not feel like they got their just
    due.
    That is very sad, many people did not, but we know they were
    all there and feel for them just the same. there were no shortage of hero’s that
    day, including her husband.

  • johnny

    The media has become so powerful that they will twist anything they want either to their benefit or for the benefit of some ‘powerful’ person who screwed up. The 9/11 situation is a good example of collective punishment meted out to the American people since the govt could not do its job – it ranges from everyday hassles at the airport to, the war that has devastated the economy and now to make matters worse – immigration reform. We will now have people coming by the throes unchecked who will claim they have been here for 20 yrs. Indians will be leading this charge – i understand a lot of social security benefecieries are Indians who never lived here.

  • Gawrence

    Are you kidding?

  • jimdep

    Why would they be kidding? I think she is spot on with her assessment.

  • http://www.facebook.com/art.faucett Art Faucett

    She is no great fan of the Bush administration. Pretty much invalidates what she says right after that. It was Clinton;s fault anyway. He dismantled our security overseas which prevented the intelligence needed to stop 9/11. At least Bush water boarded 3 people to get the intel to stop another terrorist act, and to locate Bin laden. Obama standing there, taking credit is embarrassing.. Bush was barely in office. BTW, Obama is still blaming Bush for his own “performance”. Obama is hated overseas because they don’t respect “leaders” that are impotent. He’s done everything short of attack Israel himself, by arming it’s enemies. Heck, he didn’t even visit until very recently. If i was Israel, I would have “accidentally” shot his plane down as he entered their airspace. Tit for tat..

  • http://www.facebook.com/art.faucett Art Faucett

    Are you kidding? Next time don’t smoke meth before you post.

  • TooRotten

    Clinton was too busy in the oral office to give a crap about bin laden when we had the chance to drop him dead. He was thinking with his other head. Had he said go ahead, none of it would have happened. Wondering where the heck we would be if Hillary had become President… (Shivering at the thought).

  • HBarry

    Richard Clark, a Bush I appointee who continued under Clinton as the National Coordinator for Counter-terrorism for the US would disagree with you. The guy’s August memo entitled, entitled “Bin Ladin Determined to Strike in US” was ignored by Bush Admin who tried to diminish it and Clark claims he was blown off.

  • Toby

    This plane was so obvious shot down by our own government.

  • Toby

    This plane was so obviously shot down by our own government.

Subscribe to a daily dose of news from Skift