Transport Cruises

SkiftSocial: Carnival’s missed opportunity for social media success during the Triumph crisis

@SamShankman

Feb 21, 2013 6:59 am

Skift Take

Carnival received an enormous outpouring of customer comments – both positive and negative – over the past week, but it could have been more proactive in its responses and updates given the visibility of the situation.

— Samantha Shankman

Latest Report: The Future of the Aircraft Cabin

Lyle Ratliff  / Reuters

The Carnival Triumph cruise ship is towed towards the dock as spectators watch at the port of Mobile, Alabama, February 14, 2013. Lyle Ratliff / Reuters


Carnival Cruise Lines could have turned its Triumph crisis into a social media success, but it did not. Instead it went inward, then chose to use social media as a megaphone rather than a method of two-way communication. It also had the dubious honor of being the subject of a trending hashtag on Twitter: #cruisefromhell.

As one of the more favored cruise lines on the Internet, the troubled travel giant was in a prime position to do so: It is the most liked cruise line on Facebook with 2,192,322 “Likes” and the third-most followed cruise line on Twitter with 72,643 followers.

Although it posted 20 Triumph-related posts to Facebook since the incident, it failed to use social media to update family members, press, and onlookers to the conditions and status of the Triumph during last week’s travails, choosing instead to use it as a mouthpiece from CEO Gerry Cahill’s press conference and apology session.

Carnival Facebook StatusWhen it did reach out, Carnival turned to Facebook rather than Twitter to share updates and engage with customers. Its 20 Triumph-related Facebook posts received as many as 10,038 Likes (on a post stating all passengers were home) and 3,032 comments (on a statement from Cahill).

The cruise company’s Twittter account didn’t kick into high gear until Thursday, four days after the Carnival Triumph engine fire. According to SkiftSocial, the cruise company’s average daily tweet rate for the past five years has been just over three a day, but it tweeted more than ten times that number on February 15 as passengers finally left the Carnival Triumph. The majority of the tweets were a series of apologetic and explanatory quotes from Cahill, like the following:

After the cruise line reported all passengers had disembarked on Friday, February 15, both Facebook and Twitter went silent until Tuesday, February 19, when it tweeted a link to a Facebook post on its upcoming Crew Member of the Month awards.

Carnival Tweet Rate - 9 days

Apparently even a massive public health and public relations disaster isn’t reason enough for Carnival’s social media team to speak to its consumers and the public over a holiday weekend.

Comments

Although it didn’t post updates since Friday, Carnival did continue commenting on passengers’ many Facebook posts throughout the weekend.

Carnival representatives were quick to comment on nearly every positive message posted to its Facebook page, but rarely responded to negative posts. For such a widely publicized accident, Carnival’s page has remarkably few negative comments.

Carnival did not respond to a number of inquiries from Skift regarding their social media strategy during the crisis.

For a more in-depth look at statistics on Carnival’s social media activity during the past two weeks, check out our first data dashboard, SkiftSocial Read more about SkiftSocial’s launch here, and what it means for social media monitoring in the travel industry.

Carnival’s activity by hour of the day Facebook over the past two weeks:

SkiftSocial Carnival

 

And lastly, a bonus video, from Late Night with Jimmy Fallon, from Feb 20th, a short skit on “Pros and Cons: Going on a Carnival Cruise”

Tags: , ,

Follow @SamShankman

Next Up

More on Skift

How Destinations Turn Locals Into Their Best Brand Ambassadors
American Airlines and Orbitz Worldwide Reach Flight Agreement
3 Digital Trends We’re Tracking At Skift This Week
3 Ways to Guarantee Your Next Business Trip Won’t Be All Work and No Play