Skift Take

A price cut is the absolute last thing that the cruise industry needs. There's no way Carnival and its peers can argue that their race to the bottom hasn't created conditions where accidents are much more likely. Even lower prices will arguably make things worse.

The cruise industry may be forced into cutting prices after safety concerns were raised following incidents that took place on the same day involving the ships Thomson Majesty and Carnival Triumph.

The death of five crew from Thomson Majesty and the engine-room fire that immobilised Carnival Triumph were a serious blow to the industry which has been trying to restore confidence after 32 people died when Costa Concordia crashed into rocks and capsized off Giglio in Italy in January 2012.

Although the Passenger Shipping Association says the number of UK cruise passengers hit a record 1,701,000 last year, it was an increase of just 1,000 on 2011 and more than half were past passengers taking advantage of low fares rather than the first-timers the lines need to attract.

The five crew on Thomson Majesty died during a lifeboat training exercise put in place after the Concordia disaster.

No one was hurt in the fire on Carnival Triumph, which struck while the ship was in the Gulf of Mexico, but passenger reports of four horrific days of overflowing toilets and long lines for food while the ship was rescued and towed back to shore have damaged Carnival Cruise Lines’ credentials, especially as a similar incident left Carnival Splendor stranded off the coast of Mexico in 2010.

In a survey of 2,230 Americans last month, half agreed air travel was safer than a cruise, while 58 per cent who had never cruised said they were less likely to take one now than a year ago.

To try to stem a drop in confidence, Carnival’s UK boss has promised an investigation into what went wrong on Triumph and what can be done to ensure it never happens again. Both Costa Allegra and Azamara Quest were immobilised by engine-room fires in 2012.


The Daily Newsletter

Our daily coverage of the global travel industry. Written by editors and analysts from across Skift’s brands.

Have a confidential tip for Skift? Get in touch

Tags: accidents, carnival, costa, deals

Up Next

Loading next stories