Transport Airlines

Southwest Airlines’ days as the industry maverick are numbered

Feb 11, 2013 1:13 am

Skift Take

Southwest can no longer afford to wave bag fees without finding other ways to increase profits. Perhaps Spirit, by refusing to apologize for rampant fees while offering dirt cheap fares, is the real maverick these days.

— Samantha Shankman

Latest Report: The Big Business of LGBT Travel

Corey Seeman  / Flickr

Southwest Airlines congregates at Terminal 12 in Oakland International Airport. Corey Seeman / Flickr


Southwest Airlines’ reputation as an industry maverick seems to be going the way of flight attendants in hot pants and $20 one-way fares.

The nation’s largest domestic carrier just marked its 40th straight profitable year, an unmatched feat in a time of economic turbulence, fluctuating fuel prices and airline bankruptcies. It did so by undercutting the competition with no-frills flights and, in the process, building an army of budget-minded fans.

Now many of those longtime customers say the Dallas-based carrier that calls itself LUV airlines has been losing their love since it recently began to shift its focus away from low fares and friendly service toward swelling its bottom line.

Among the changes that critics say show Southwest’s new profit-boosting attitude: It cut the legroom on many planes to fit more seats, retooled its frequent flier program to make passengers spend more money to collect points and adopted new fees to board early.

“Southwest used to be a great airline,” said Lance Malkind, a semi-retired consulting actuary from Phoenix, who has been flying Southwest for 33 years. “The fares were reasonable, onboard service was excellent, and the frequent flier plan was simple and very good. Now the fares are no longer that good compared to other airlines, and the frequent flier plan has gone from being one of the best to one of the worst.”

Southwest is still the country’s only major airline to waive fees for the first two checked bags. It also ranks high in on-time performance. But even airline officials conceded that Southwest had to find new ways to make money to compete.

“Yes, we have to keep up with the times and, yes, we have to change,” said Whitney Eichinger, a spokeswoman for the airline. “But the truth is that Southwest remains a maverick in the industry.”

Many of the new fees adopted in the last couple of years are for optional services, such as early boarding and wireless Internet access, she said. But what has long been included in the price of the fare — two checked bags, snacks and drinks — remains free, Eichinger added.

“If we were charging for peanuts, that is something that our customers would find outrageous,” she said.

Because Southwest has forgone millions of dollars in revenue from baggage fees, analysts say, it was no surprise that the airline would look for other ways to generate extra cash to offset rising labor and fuel costs.

“Southwest is in the middle between customers who are very sensitive to higher fares and investors, on the other hand, complaining that the airline is not doing enough,” said Seth Kaplan, a managing partner at Airlines Weekly, a trade publication.

With the economy rebounding and demand for air travel still relatively strong, airline industry experts say now is the best time for Southwest to test new moneymaking ideas without risking the loss of too many loyal fans.

“I’m not surprised by this,” said Betsy Snyder, an analyst with Standard & Poor’s. “They want to increase their profits and this is the way to do it. They could lose passengers, but in some markets what’s the option? Do other airlines offer anything better?”

Southwest was born in 1971, serving Dallas, Houston and San Antonio with three Boeing 737s — a plane that still represents nearly 90% of its fleet. It made its headquarters at Dallas’ Love Field, which later earned it the stock symbol LUV.

The airline took to the air amid tough competition from now-defunct Braniff and Texas International and fought back by offering free bottles of liquor and half-price fares for overnight flights.

Almost from the beginning, Southwest has pushed its niche — low fares but no extra frills like seat assignments, in-flight meals or roomy first-class seats. The hot-pants uniforms worn by flight attendants in the 1970s were replaced with shorts and pants in the ’80s.

Southwest enjoyed its best years in the late 1990s when it saved millions of dollars with fuel hedging contracts that enabled the airline to buy fuel at a fixed price to avoid the exposure of price fluctuations. But the hedging advantage ended around 2008 when fuel prices dropped.

As the Great Recession took hold, most other airlines added baggage fees to boost revenue. Southwest, instead, broke from the trend and adopted a “bags fly free” policy. JetBlue is the only other airline to waive fees for the first checked bag, but it doesn’t for the second.

Southwest officials said the bags-fly-free policy is probably responsible for increasing Southwest’s market share about 2% since 2008 and generates up to $1 billion annually.

To further expand its customer base, Southwest announced a $1.4-billion deal in 2010 to acquire Orlando, Fla.-based AirTran Airways.

Still, under pressure to increase profits, Southwest adopted several changes in the last two years that have angered some passengers.

In 2011, Southwest retooled its frequent flier program to award points based on fares paid instead of total flights.

To squeeze six extra seats onto each plane, Southwest announced last year a new cabin design for most of its planes that will include seats with thinner cushions, less recline and reduced legroom. Eichinger said that despite the reduction in space, the seats are lighter and more comfortable.

This year, the airline increased fees to check a third bag or an overweight or oversized bag and added a fee to board early. It also plans to enforce a new fee this year for passengers who miss a flight without first calling to cancel. The fee amount has yet to be announced.

Although Southwest has reported profits for 40 straight years, the margin has been dropping, to 2.44% in 2012 from 4.54% in 2010, according to Robert Herbst, a consultant and founder of AirlineFinancials.com.

The latest policy change to dishearten fans was an optional $40 fee to be among the first 15 passengers seated — a fee that Tammy Romo, Southwest’s chief financial officer, said could generate “tens of millions” of dollars.

The fee, announced in January, spurred lots of complaints on Southwest’s Facebook page.

“You use to be my favorite but now you are doing the same as every other airline by nickel and diming us,” Rekha Sharma-Crawford of Overland Park, Kan., posted on the site. “$40 fees for early boarding. Where’s the luv?”

Southwest has also received negative news coverage in the last few years for booting from its flights high-profile passengers such as Green Day frontman Billie Joe Armstrong (for wearing low-hanging pants) and director Kevin Smith (for being too big for his seat). Actress Leisha Hailey was tossed after a confrontation over her kissing her girlfriend.

With the added fees and more crowded cabins, Southwest is taking a chance at losing some customers, but analysts say the airline can’t sit idle while competitors rake in baggage fees. Delta Air Lines, for example, collected more than $860 million from such fees in 2011.

Henry Harteveldt, a travel industry analyst with New York-based Hudson Crossing, predicts the latest fees and policy changes at Southwest will turn away few, if any, airline customers.

“A lot of people say they will stop flying an airline,” he said. “What remains to be seen is how many of the people who say they will stop flying really do so.”

Tom Bricker, an Indianapolis attorney, is one of those longtime Southwest customers who said he had been disappointed with the airline lately.

Southwest no longer offers the lowest fares, he said. The airline showers him with promotional emails, but the offers come with lots of limitations and exclusions.

But will he abandon Southwest?

“In the end, I’ll still fly Southwest when they have the lowest fares,” he said, “but that’s happening far less frequently.”

(c)2013 the Los Angeles Times. Distributed by MCT Information Services.

Tags: ,

Next Up

More on Skift

Mobile Events App DoubleDutch Secures $19 Million in Funding
Qunar CEO on Cash Burn: ‘I Don’t Care About Short-Term Losses’
Skift Business Traveler: United Tries to Woo Back Premium Fliers With Food
Why You Should Consider Hotel Loyalty Programs