American Airlines original designer Massimo Vignelli hates its redesign
Massimo Vignelli in DC, talks about his DC Metro map design, which he originally did in 1976. Jason / Flickr.com
Good design is good forever is his contention, and says AA’s new design won’t last the next 25 years.
Excerpt from BusinessWeek
Q&A in BusinessWeek with designer Massimo Vignelli, the creator of the American Airlines’ outgoing logo.
What do you think of the redesign?
It has no sense of permanence. The American flag is great…But the American flag has 13 stripes, right? Not 11. Did American add only 11 stripes [to the flag on the tail] because they are in Chapter 11? I don’t think two more stripes would have been a disaster. And there are only two colors shown instead of all three. So is it a different flag?
What about the new logo?
Now they have something other than Helvetica that’s not as good or as powerful. Then they did a funny thing: Some may see an eagle [next to it], some may see something else. And they don’t even say it’s the eagle—they say it could be the eagle.